iGive, you receive insecurity
I've been delaying the posting of this blog entry, but since there haven't been any new developments I thought I should finally post it...
iGive.com is a website that allows people to shop at popular e-commerce retailers and have a small percentage of the purchase sent to a charity that you nominate. In theory it's a nice idea, however I've noticed a few problems with their implementation, particularly in regard to the security and confidentiality of the personal information of members that sign up. distributed.net has been using iGive since 1997, though my opinion of them has been lowered as a result of this (and other actions that are not covered here).
iGive elected to belong to the TRUSTe "web privacy seal" program, which has the goal of providing some assurance to internet users that their privacy can be safely entrusted to a website. Most of TRUSTe's assurance comes from requiring websites to pay a certification fee and have a privacy policy that complies with TRUSTe requirements, but they don't actually seem to do their own auditing unless someone makes a complaint. There are other critics that claim that TRUSTe does not take a proactive role in monitoring or punishing organizations.
( Read more )
TRUSTe recently made a blog post warning that "encoding an ID# in the URL or relying on another mechanism that can be changed by the user risks exposing data". I don't know if iGive qualifies as a "major consumer web site ... [that exposes] passports", but I'm sure they were at least attempting to aggregate the lessons from iGive's problems in that post.
iGive.com is a website that allows people to shop at popular e-commerce retailers and have a small percentage of the purchase sent to a charity that you nominate. In theory it's a nice idea, however I've noticed a few problems with their implementation, particularly in regard to the security and confidentiality of the personal information of members that sign up. distributed.net has been using iGive since 1997, though my opinion of them has been lowered as a result of this (and other actions that are not covered here).
iGive elected to belong to the TRUSTe "web privacy seal" program, which has the goal of providing some assurance to internet users that their privacy can be safely entrusted to a website. Most of TRUSTe's assurance comes from requiring websites to pay a certification fee and have a privacy policy that complies with TRUSTe requirements, but they don't actually seem to do their own auditing unless someone makes a complaint. There are other critics that claim that TRUSTe does not take a proactive role in monitoring or punishing organizations.
( Read more )
TRUSTe recently made a blog post warning that "encoding an ID# in the URL or relying on another mechanism that can be changed by the user risks exposing data". I don't know if iGive qualifies as a "major consumer web site ... [that exposes] passports", but I'm sure they were at least attempting to aggregate the lessons from iGive's problems in that post.

